Click here to receive your FREE subscription to Campus Technology
Exclusive Interview
Desire2Learn CEO Makes Case Against Blackboard Patent, Court Ruling
A conversation with Desire2Learn's John Baker and Diane Lank
3/17/2008
So that's a bit of an example. But John is right. We absolutely challenged the validity of the patent.
Nagel: Were you the trial lawyer on this case?
Lank: Oh no, no. We have outside counsel. I was at counsel table the whole time, but no....
Baker: And I think I was the only corporate representative from both sides that actually sat through the entire trial.
Nagel. Okay. In terms of your legal options, where are you going from here?
Baker: I think the two main things that we're doing right now is, one, we're going to be filing some motions in terms of dealing some judgments as a matter of law with the current judge. And secondly we're going to be putting this in for appeal to take it to a higher court.... We'll have a much better chance of pleading our case there in that forum than necessarily what we had in the jury verdict.
[Baker then went on to praise the efforts of the jury, the judge, clerks, and others involved in the trial at some length. This kind of information can be read at D2L's Patent Information Blog.]
Everyone keeps referring to Blackboard as winning here. But really they only got about 20 percent of what went to the jury and less than 10 percent of what they originally wanted, which was over $50 million, by the way, not the $17 [million] that's been reported so far to date. The judge threw out their willful case before it went to jury verdict....
It was shocking to me listening to our case being presented because there was certain evidence I had never seen until it went into an open trial, and it was incredibly frustrating at the same time to understand what this competitor was doing to get one win against us.
Nagel: Can you give me a timeframe for the motions you want to file and also filing for appeal? You can ballpark it.
Baker: The motions should be probably in within the next week or two. And the appeal, if it's heard, probably within the next year or so.
Lank: Well, back up a little bit: Only if we don't prevail on our post-trial motions will it go to appeal. So if we don't get the remedies we seek through the post-trial motions, then it will go to appeal. Now, I think it's likely it will go to appeal because I expect that the judge won't give us everything we want.
Baker: But we never know.
Lank: But you don't know.
Baker: This judge seems to ... really understand the case a lot better now after ... hearing us talk about it for probably two or three weeks. We have high expectations of this judge.
Nagel: I'd like to talk about the patent a little bit. What's going on with the reexamination? Correct my Latin if I'm wrong, but you filed an inter partes reexam in February 2007?
Lank: No, we filed our inter partes reexam application in December of 2006. It was in February of 2007 that our petition for reexam was granted.
Recommended Reading
- Sun, Stanford Working To Archive History
In May in San Francisco, experts from leading universities, libraries, and research institutions around the world met as part of an ongoing effort to address a pressing issue: archiving the world's history, right up to today.
- The Quilt Coalition Rolls Out XO Communications for High-Capacity Network Services
The Quilt, a coalition of 28 regional network organizations, has added XO Communications Services to its authorized vendor list. The Quilt represents 200 universities and thousands of other educational institutions across the United States. With this new relationship, Quilt members can purchase XO's high-speed IP transit and network transport services at competitive rates.
- Wimba Classroom 5.2 Expands Classroom Capture Support, Adds MP3 Downloads
At the NECC 2008 conference in Texas this week, Wimba launched a new version of Wimba Classroom, the virtual classroom component of the company's Collaboration Suite. The new 5.2 release expands options for classroom capture and adds a variety of other functional and ease of use features.
- Automation Chimera: Education Is Not Management
The lure of automating workflow online so human intervention is minimized is continually reinforced in the minds of higher education administrators by examples of automated campus systems such as financials, student information systems, and other enterprise systems. But what's good for management is not always good for learning.
- Cognos Releases BI Software for Linux-based IBM System z Mainframe
Cognos, which IBM acquired in January, has released an update to its business intelligence software that will run on the Linux operating system on IBM System z mainframes. IBM Cognos 8 BI was being developed by the two companies prior to the acquisition, but assimilation of Cognos into IBM accelerated development.
- Facebook and Collegiality: A Serendipitous Social Niche
Facebook is a way to greet a colleague as if she or he is on your own campus: a wave at a distance, a hello at the corner burrito place, a honk as you both leave the campus parking lot. Informal collegiality has been extended over the miles.
