Click here to receive your FREE subscription to Campus Technology
Featured News
USPTO Rejects Blackboard Patent Claims
3/28/2008
He said that it wasn't just one piece of prior art that knocked down the patent claims, but multiple pieces, which makes the present decision stronger than it would be if there were less prior art involved.
"It's going to make it very difficult for Blackboard to overcome the recent office action from the Patent and Trademark Office."
He continued, "We do believe Blackboard has a significant hurdle to overcome here given the number of pieces of prior art that caused this to be rejected."
Diane Lank, general counsel for Desire2Learn, said that the company expected the USPTO to reject Blackboard's patent claims all along, despite the fact that a jury in Texas did not invalidate the patent last month when it had the opportunity to do so.
"We knew going into this thing that the patent had very, very serious, likely fatal, flaws," Lank said. "The one thing you have to remember is they go on different standards. The court case, to invalidate the patent, is a different standard of proof that we had to show there--a 'clear and convincing' standard. The Patent and Trademark Office isn't governed by that rule."
As for Desire2Learn's next steps in terms of the patent infringement case, "We're just digesting this now," Baker said.
The information is still very new. As of this writing, Desire2Learn had not yet received the letter from the Patent Office directly; the notice is posted on the USPTO's site, which is how Baker found out about it, doing a random search on the site.
"For us, it's a note coming from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office ... that validates what we've been saying all along, that this patent should have never issued and that if the Patent and Trademark Office had this prior art in front of them that they would invalidate it," Baker said. "And that's what they have done here with this action: They've rejected all 44 claims. It's been a long [time], almost two years we've been saying that, and now finally we're seeing some great results from it. We just wish it would have happened a couple months prior to the trial."
Desire2Learn, of course, lost the patent infringement case Blackboard had brought against it and was ordered to pay $3.1 million in damages and remove "infringing" code from its learning management system.
Desire2Learn did, in fact, remove the code from its system and released version 8.3 as a final design workaround. However, Desire2Learn said the USPTO's action would not affect the latest release of its software. The reason? When the workaround was implemented, the software turned out to be an improvement over previous releases, incorporating not just the code changes but several new features as well.
"Regardless of what the final actions out of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office are--and we're thrilled with the direction they're going in--we should be in a position where our clients and potential clients are going to be well separated from what Blackboard's trying to claim as an invention because we put the energy into addressing all the things they were trying to claim were infringing."
Recommended Reading
- IBM Unveils New Software Designed To Streamline eDiscovery
IBM has announced the release of new Enterprise Content Management (ECM) software specifically designed to meet the needs of clients dealing with complex legal discovery requirements. The eDiscovery solutions expand on IBM's ECM platform and are intended to give organizations greater control of digitally stored documents in an effort to reduce costs and streamline the discovery process involved in litigation.
- Microsoft Releases SQL Server 2008 to Manufacturing
Microsoft has released SQL Server 2008 to manufacturing (RTM) and, as an evaluation edition, to subscribers of its Microsoft Development Network and TechNet services, the company announced Wednesday.
- Security Woes Up, as PHP and OSS Make the List
Software vulnerabilities are up this year, especially Web browser-based ones, according to a new report from IBM Internet Security Systems. The X-Force 2008 Mid-Year Trend Statistics Report, released in late July, defined the problem broadly. A vulnerability is anything that results "in a weakening or breakdown of the confidentiality, integrity, or accessibility of the computing system."
- Textbook Publishing in a Flat World
According to the National Association of College Stores in a 2007 survey, the average cost of a new college textbook was $53. The founders of Flat World Knowledge, which launches with its first run of college textbooks this fall, consider that too high--so high, in fact, that they'll be offering textbooks for free, at least in versions that can be read online.
- CourseCast 2.0 Adds Podcasting, Streaming Media Features to Free Lecture Capture System
Panopto has released CourseCast 2.0, an update to the company's classroom capture system that's available free to academic users. CourseCast 2.0 had previously been available as part of Panopto's beta program for educators since June.
- It IS about Technology: Integrating Higher Ed into Knowledge Culture
For more than twenty years, we educational technologists have talked about "integrating information technology into higher education." The implication was that education would stay the same and information technology would benignly slip in and cause no ruckus at all. This rhetoric no longer applies, if it ever did, and does a disservice to us as we work through the intricacies of this age.
