Blackboard Trial Against Desire2Learn in Court

  • By Dian Schaffhauser
  • 02/14/08

Just a week after higher education software maker Blackboard announced "tremendous" financial results for the year, it is finally facing off in a small-town Texas court against rival Desire2Learn in a patent dispute over e-learning software. Blackboard is seeking $17 million in lost revenue as well as an injunction against the company, which is based in Canada.

Immediately after receiving a patent on its course management system in 2006, the larger company filed suit against Desire2Learn, claiming patent infringement.

Many participants in the e-learning community charged that the patent award was overly broad and ignored previous offerings in the e-learning space. The response became so heated that Blackboard eventually issued a "legally binding" guarantee promising never to take legal action against participants in three open-source projects, Moodle, Sakai, and ATutor.

For its part, Desire2Learn has challenged the patent. But no decision has been made yet by the federal patent office on the validity of the original claim.

According to a report in The Chronicle of Higher Education Blackboard president, Michael Chasen, reiterated that point on day one of the trial, stating that "his company had no intention of suing colleges that use open-source software to create their own course-management systems."

Desire2Learn has around 500 clients in the United States, compared with Blackboard's 2,400.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • MathGPT

    MathGPT AI Tutor Now Out of Beta

    Ed tech provider GotIt! Education has announced the general availability of MathGPT, an AI tutor and teaching assistant for foundational math support.

  • person signing a bill at a desk with a faint glow around the document. A tablet and laptop are subtly visible in the background, with soft colors and minimal digital elements

    California Governor Signs AI Content Safeguards into Law

    California Governor Gavin Newsom has officially signed off on a series of landmark artificial intelligence bills, signaling the state’s latest efforts to regulate the burgeoning technology, particularly in response to the misuse of sexually explicit deepfakes. The legislation is aimed at mitigating the risks posed by AI-generated content, as concerns grow over the technology's potential to manipulate images, videos, and voices in ways that could cause significant harm.

  • white desk with an open digital tablet showing AI-related icons like gears and neural networks

    Elon University and AAC&U Release Student Guide to AI

    A new publication from Elon University 's Imagining the Digital Future Center and the American Association of Colleges and Universities offers students key principles for navigating college in the age of artificial intelligence.

  • abstract technology icons connected by lines and dots

    Digital Layers and Human Ties: Navigating the CIO's Dilemma in Higher Education

    As technology permeates every aspect of life on campus, efficiency and convenience may come at the cost of human connection and professional identity.