Report Examines College Practices that Hold High-Achieving, Low-Income Students Back

Concerns about college costs such as room and board and extra fees "discourage" 34 percent of high-achieving high school seniors from low-income backgrounds from applying to any college. More than two in five (44 percent) never visit their "top choice" school, and almost one in four (23 percent) apply with no help from parents, teachers or school counselors. These students had a GPA above 3.8 and SAT or ACT scores in the top 15 percent nationwide. Those findings come out of a new web survey among 2,500 students who applied for a scholarship from the Jack Kent Cooke Foundation, which also published the research.

"Opening Doors, How Selective Colleges and Universities Are Expanding Access for High-Achieving, Low-Income Students" examines the challenges these high-achieving students face and offers guidance for how elite colleges can "open their doors wider" to outstanding low-income students.

Many of the questions students answered pointed out many small ways colleges and universities could help their candidates through the application process more effectively:

  • Did you request that the application fee be waived? Thirty-five percent respondents said they didn't request that. Among that third, almost three-quarters (71 percent) said they didn’t think they'd qualify; another 17 percent said they didn't know it could be waived. In only 6 percent of cases did the students say the fee was "automatically waived."
  • Did you visit your top choice institution's campus before deciding to apply? Half said they did — at their own expense; another 44 percent said they didn't, most because they couldn't afford to. Again, in just 6 percent of the cases did students receive financial assistance from the institution to make the visit.
  • Who helped you complete your college application? Slightly more than half (52 percent) had help from parents; 49 percent said they had help from a school counselor; and two in 10 said they had nobody's help (23 percent) or had a friend's help (21 percent). Only 10 percent said staff at the institution provided assistance.

An "action plan" offered 14 practices schools could adopt to encourage these high achievers "to apply, improve their chances of admission and encourage [them] to enroll" once they've been admitted.

A biggie: "Make clear the true cost of college attendance after financial aid." As the report explained, many low-income students and their families don't realize that the high "sticker prices" of institutions are just the starting point and that financial aid may put the actual expense below the cost of the local community college.

Another suggestion: Reduce the expense of applying to college and make the mechanisms for waiving application fees "prominent" on the institution's website.

"For generations, higher education served as a springboard to social mobility, offering a gateway to the American Dream. Sadly, that dream is no longer a reality for the many students in financial need," said Jeff Selingo, founding director of the Arizona State/Georgetown University Academy for Innovative Higher Education Leadership, who wrote the new report's foreword. "The demographics of today's college students are diverse and changing. Colleges and universities must evolve to meet their needs, and this report provides a road map."

The report is available on the Cooke Foundation website here, along with an executive summary and video.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • college students in a classroom focus on a silver laptop, with a neural network diagram on the monitor in the background

    Report: 93% of Students Believe Gen AI Training Belongs in Degree Programs

    The vast majority of today's college students — 93% — believe generative AI training should be included in degree programs, according to a recent Coursera report. What's more, 86% of students consider gen AI the most crucial technical skill for career preparation, prioritizing it above in-demand skills such as data strategy and software development.

  • laptop with a neural network image, surrounded by books, notebooks, a magnifying glass, a pencil cup, and a desk lamp

    D2L Lumi AI Updates Add Personalized Study Supports

    Learning platform D2L has announced new artificial intelligence features for D2L Lumi that help provide more personalized study supports for students.

  • three glowing stacks of tech-themed icons

    Research: LLMs Need a Translation Layer to Launch Complex Cyber Attacks

    While large language models have been touted for their potential in cybersecurity, they are still far from executing real-world cyber attacks — unless given help from a new kind of abstraction layer, according to researchers at Carnegie Mellon University and Anthropic.

  • young man in a denim jacket scans his phone at a card reader outside a modern glass building

    Colleges Roll Out Mobile Credential Technology

    Allegion US has announced a partnership with Florida Institute of Technology (FIT) and Denison College, in conjunction with Transact + CBORD, to install mobile credential technologies campuswide. Implementing Mobile Student ID into Apple Wallet and Google Wallet will allow students access to campus facilities, amenities, and residence halls using just their phones.