Fewer Admissions Offices Using Student Social Media to Influence Acceptance Decisions

While most admissions officers consider checking out the social media profiles of college applicants "fair game," few actually do so. At the same time, a growing number of high schoolers agree that colleges and universities have the right to view their social media activity.

In a recent set of surveys, Kaplan Test Prep queried 388 admissions leaders from top U.S. colleges and universities as well as 914 high school students who have attended a Kaplan course. Among the first group, 68 percent reported having no qualms about checking out student social media profiles on sites such as Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Just 29 percent said they have actually done it. That's down from last year's 35 percent.

Among those admissions officers who called the social checkup "fair game," they explained their reasoning as follows:

  • "Employers do it all the time. Colleges can do it as well."
  • "I think if things are publicly accessible without undue intrusion, it's OK. If it's searchable, it's fair game."
  • "We don't do this, but we could. I think high school seniors make poor choices sometimes when they put stuff online."

Respondents who considered social searching an "invasion of privacy" offered these reasons:

  • "Their application should be the sole decider."
  • "We use social media for recruitment, not admissions."
  • "We only look at social media if the applicant includes or provides it."

Among the students, 70 percent would expect admissions officers to check up on their online profiles, up from 58 percent in 2014.

Just a fraction of institutions forbid admissions officers from adding an online checkup to the application consideration process. While 20 percent said their schools have official guidelines or policies on social media vetting, only a third of those — about seven institutions in every 100 — added that they're not permitted to do so.

Some of the decline in social media checks may be attributable to changing habits among young people, who have moved from Facebook to "non-archival" platforms such as Snapchat.

"You cannot visit an applicant's social media profile if you can't locate them, and as one admissions officer shared with us, 'Students are harder to find,'" said Yariv Alpher, executive director of research for Kaplan Test Prep, in a press release. "They've gotten savvier in hiding or curating their social media footprints, even as they've become very comfortable with the notion of having a digital presence to begin with."

As he noted, most admissions officers are "sticking with the traditional elements of the application," including test scores, grade point average, recommendation letters and personal essays. "For most, these traditional factors provide enough useful information to make a decision, like it has for generations of their predecessors."

Of course, any offer can be revoked if the school later uncovers evidence of malfeasance on the part of the applicant. Just ask the Harvard admittees who lost their acceptance status last year when they posted highly offensive memes on a private Facebook group for incoming freshmen. It happens more often than one might imagine, according to the Kaplan survey: Nine percent of admissions officers had revoked an offer of admission because of something they'd uncovered online.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • abstract pattern of shapes, arrows and circuit lines

    Internet2 Announces a New President and CEO to Step Up in October

    Internet2, the member-driven nonprofit offering advanced network technology services and cyberinfrastructure to the research and education community has completed its search, which began this past May, for a new president and CEO to take the helm.

  • shield with an AI microchip emblem hovering above stacks of gold coins

    AI Security Spend Surges While Traditional Security Budgets Shrink

    A new Thales report reveals that while enterprises are pouring resources into AI-specific protections, only 8% are encrypting the majority of their sensitive cloud data — leaving critical assets exposed even as AI-driven threats escalate and traditional security budgets shrink.

  • stack of gold coins disintegrates into digital particles against a dark circuit-board background with glowing AI imagery

    MIT Report: Most Organizations See No Business Return on Gen AI Investments

    A recent report out of the MIT Media Lab found that despite $30-40 billion in enterprise spending on generative AI, 95% of organizations are seeing no business return.

  • young man in a denim jacket scans his phone at a card reader outside a modern glass building

    Colleges Roll Out Mobile Credential Technology

    Allegion US has announced a partnership with Florida Institute of Technology (FIT) and Denison College, in conjunction with Transact + CBORD, to install mobile credential technologies campuswide. Implementing Mobile Student ID into Apple Wallet and Google Wallet will allow students access to campus facilities, amenities, and residence halls using just their phones.