College Students Overestimate Importance of Major Selection for Job Prospects

woman in graduation cap looking up at formulas

While the majority of college students in a recent survey believe their major selection is a key determinant of future job prospects, only 50 percent of employers analyzed in the study specified a major requirement for job listings. Why? Employers are increasingly focusing on job skills, according to Handshake, a career community that connects students and graduates with employers across the United States.

The survey, conducted by Propeller Insights on behalf of Handshake, polled 1,004 U.S. college students mostly between the ages of 16 and 24 about their majors and career expectations, and analyzed hiring data from employers using the Handshake Premium platform.

Among the findings:

  • 61 percent of students feel pressured to choose a major that they believe will result in a high-paying job;
  • Men were 53 percent more likely than women to choose a major for its earning potential, while women were 27 percent more likely than men to be influenced by academic passion;
  • 63 percent of students would take the first job they were offered because they need the money;
  • Women were more likely than men to be concerned about a recession impacting their job prospects, and more likely to try to "get a job quickly" once out of college;
  • Nearly four times more men than women major in engineering (20 percent vs. 6 percent);
  • Engineering students ranked "relevant skills" as the most important factor in finding a job, while all other majors prioritized "prior internship/job experience";
  • Students in humanities majors were the only group in which the majority of respondents did not feel pressured to choose a major that would result in a high-paying job; and
  • Humanities students were also the only group in which the majority listed "satisfying work" (as opposed to "pay") as the primary driver when looking for and choosing a job.

"The overemphasis on the relationship between major and career prospects is outdated and needs to be reevaluated," commented Christine Cruzvergara, vice president of higher education and student success at Handshake, in a statement. "To succeed in finding meaningful and satisfying careers post-graduation, students should shift to developing a new mindset. They should focus on developing skills including the ability to synthesize information, think critically, and communicate well, which will serve them both in college and beyond."

About the Author

Rhea Kelly is editor in chief for Campus Technology, THE Journal, and Spaces4Learning. She can be reached at [email protected].

Featured

  • abstract illustration of a glowing AI-themed bar graph on a dark digital background with circuit patterns

    Stanford 2025 AI Index Reveals Surge in Adoption, Investment, and Global Impact as Trust and Regulation Lag Behind

    Stanford University's Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI) has released its AI Index Report 2025, measuring AI's diverse impacts over the past year.

  • modern college building with circuit and brain motifs

    Anthropic Launches Claude for Education

    Anthropic has announced a version of its Claude AI assistant tailored for higher education institutions. Claude for Education "gives academic institutions secure, reliable AI access for their entire community," the company said, to enable colleges and universities to develop and implement AI-enabled approaches across teaching, learning, and administration.

  • lightbulb

    Call for Speakers Now Open for Tech Tactics in Education: Overcoming Roadblocks to Innovation

    The annual virtual conference from the producers of Campus Technology and THE Journal will return on September 25, 2025, with a focus on emerging trends in cybersecurity, data privacy, AI implementation, IT leadership, building resilience, and more.

  • From Fire TV to Signage Stick: University of Utah's Digital Signage Evolution

    Jake Sorensen, who oversees sponsorship and advertising and Student Media in Auxiliary Business Development at the University of Utah, has navigated the digital signage landscape for nearly 15 years. He was managing hundreds of devices on campus that were incompatible with digital signage requirements and needed a solution that was reliable and lowered labor costs. The Amazon Signage Stick, specifically engineered for digital signage applications, gave him the stability and design functionality the University of Utah needed, along with the assurance of long-term support.