Measuring True Post-College Employment Outcomes Is a Fool's Errand

group of business people with data chart superimposed

A college in Texas reports on its website that between 62 and 65 percent of its vocational nursing program graduates got jobs as licensed practical and licensed vocational nurses. Yet, according to the school's accreditation agency, the job placement rate for those same graduates was just 33 percent. Which one's right? It's possible that neither is, because there's no consistency in how employment data is collected or reported.

That's the topic of a report recently produced by the Institute for College Access & Success. This non-profit works to make higher education "more available and affordable" for everybody through "research, analysis and advocacy."

According to "Of Metrics and Markets: Measuring Post-College Employment Success," the problem starts with a lack of coordination among the "three entities tasked with oversight" of higher ed — the accrediting agencies, state governments and federal government — each pursuing their own approach to calculating and reporting employment metrics. The result is a "patchwork" of data that makes comparing programs and colleges "nearly impossible."

On top of that, when the metrics are available, people who need them may have trouble finding them. Recently, the U.S. Department of Education removed data from its College Scorecard related to employment outcomes for institutions, and the federal agency has also done away with requirements that colleges even share job placement rates with their prospective students.

The Institute called for creation of job rates that are "consistent, accurate and transparent enough to inform decision-making." It also offered an alternative approach for creating these:

First, the report suggested that the feds take the lead in coming up with a uniform definition for job placement rate to be used by all parties, predicated on measuring the percentage of graduates who are employed in the occupations for which they were trained; also, the report noted, states should do the job of verifying the data (to prevent misleading and falsified reporting).

Second, the report encouraged the Department of Education to "restore" the threshold earnings rate metric and improve the calculation by adding threshold earnings rates at the program level along with the school level. Right now, the only salary data is the median earning of all former students in an institution who received federal financial aid at the 10-year mark after entering the school.

Third, the Institute would like to see Congress authorize the creation of a federal student-level data network that would improve the accuracy of the calculations done for federal employment metrics.

"Higher education proves a powerful lever of upward mobility for many Americans, but leaves too many worse off than when they started, with substantial debt and little or no increased earnings power to pay it off," said Institute President James Kvaal, in a statement. "Simply put, students are entitled to this foundational information as they make key decisions about where to invest time and money."

The report is openly available on the Institute for College Access & Success website.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • abstract illustration of a glowing AI-themed bar graph on a dark digital background with circuit patterns

    Stanford 2025 AI Index Reveals Surge in Adoption, Investment, and Global Impact as Trust and Regulation Lag Behind

    Stanford University's Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence (HAI) has released its AI Index Report 2025, measuring AI's diverse impacts over the past year.

  • modern college building with circuit and brain motifs

    Anthropic Launches Claude for Education

    Anthropic has announced a version of its Claude AI assistant tailored for higher education institutions. Claude for Education "gives academic institutions secure, reliable AI access for their entire community," the company said, to enable colleges and universities to develop and implement AI-enabled approaches across teaching, learning, and administration.

  • lightbulb

    Call for Speakers Now Open for Tech Tactics in Education: Overcoming Roadblocks to Innovation

    The annual virtual conference from the producers of Campus Technology and THE Journal will return on September 25, 2025, with a focus on emerging trends in cybersecurity, data privacy, AI implementation, IT leadership, building resilience, and more.

  • From Fire TV to Signage Stick: University of Utah's Digital Signage Evolution

    Jake Sorensen, who oversees sponsorship and advertising and Student Media in Auxiliary Business Development at the University of Utah, has navigated the digital signage landscape for nearly 15 years. He was managing hundreds of devices on campus that were incompatible with digital signage requirements and needed a solution that was reliable and lowered labor costs. The Amazon Signage Stick, specifically engineered for digital signage applications, gave him the stability and design functionality the University of Utah needed, along with the assurance of long-term support.