Study: Generative AI Could Inhibit Critical Thinking

A new study on how knowledge workers engage in critical thinking found that workers with higher confidence in generative AI technology tend to employ less critical thinking to AI-generated outputs than workers with higher confidence in personal skills, who tended to apply more critical thinking to verify, refine, and critically integrate AI responses.

The study ("The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking: Self-Reported Reductions in Cognitive Effort and Confidence Effects From a Survey of Knowledge Workers"), conducted by Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon University scientists, surveyed 319 knowledge workers who reported using AI tools such as ChatGPT and Copilot at least once a week. The researchers analyzed 936 real-world examples of AI-assisted tasks.

"[W]e find that knowledge workers engage in critical thinking primarily to ensure the quality of their work," the researchers wrote, "e.g. by verifying outputs against external sources. Moreover, while gen AI can improve worker efficiency, it can inhibit critical engagement with work and can potentially lead to long-term overreliance on the tool and diminished skill for independent problem solving."

According to the researchers, gen AI is eroding critical thinking by fundamentally changing how professionals deal with certain business tasks, specifically in these three areas:

  • Information gathering and verification: AI automates the retrieval and organization of data, reducing the effort needed to find information. However, workers must now spend more time verifying AI-generated content for accuracy and reliability.
  • Problem-solving and AI response integration: Instead of solving problems independently, workers focus on refining and adapting AI outputs to meet their specific needs, including adjusting tone, context, and relevance.
  • Task execution and task stewardship: Rather than performing tasks directly, workers oversee AI processes, guiding and evaluating outputs to ensure quality. While gen AI handles routine work, responsibility and accountability remain with human users.

While gen AI reduces cognitive effort in some areas, it increases the need for verification, integration, and oversight, reinforcing the importance of maintaining critical thinking skills. For this effort, researchers suggest future development of gen AI tools to facilitate higher critical thinking. This can be done by integrating feedback mechanisms that can help users gauge the reliability of gen AI outputs. Further, tools should be designed to customize AI assistance levels, based on a user's task confidence and expertise.

"We find that knowledge workers often refrain from critical thinking when they lack the skills to inspect, improve, and guide AI-generated responses," the researchers wrote. "GenAI tools could incorporate features that facilitate user learning, such as providing explanations of AI reasoning, suggesting areas for user refinement, or offering guided critiques."

About the Author

Chris Paoli (@ChrisPaoli5) is the associate editor for Converge360.

Featured

  • NVIDIA DGX line

    NVIDIA Intros Personal AI Supercomputers

    NVIDIA has introduced a new lineup of AI-powered computing solutions designed to accelerate enterprise workloads.

  • geometric pattern of interconnected triangles and hexagons

    Gravyty Merges with AI-Powered Student Engagement Companies Ivy.ai and Ocelot

    Gravyty, a provider of alumni and donor engagement and fundraising solutions, has announced a merger with AI-powered student enrollment and engagement companies Ivy.ai and Ocelot. The combined company will operate under the Gravyty brand.

  • From Fire TV to Signage Stick: University of Utah's Digital Signage Evolution

    Jake Sorensen, who oversees sponsorship and advertising and Student Media in Auxiliary Business Development at the University of Utah, has navigated the digital signage landscape for nearly 15 years. He was managing hundreds of devices on campus that were incompatible with digital signage requirements and needed a solution that was reliable and lowered labor costs. The Amazon Signage Stick, specifically engineered for digital signage applications, gave him the stability and design functionality the University of Utah needed, along with the assurance of long-term support.

  • two abstract humanoid figures made of interconnected lines and polygons, glowing slightly against a dark gradient background

    Microsoft Introduces Copilot Chat Agents for Education

    Microsoft recently announced Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat, a new pay-as-you-go offering that adds AI agents to its existing free chat tool for Microsoft 365 education customers.